I’ve decided to post some original puzzles here on puzzlinks.com. There are two reasons for this. First, what’s a puzzle blog without orignal puzzles? Second, I realized after I posted my entry on Mochikoro a while back that there are very few places to find such puzzles on the English web. So, I decided to create some of my own. As you may be able to guess from the title of this post, I’m hoping it will be a weekly feature. Right now, I’m shooting for a 20 week run.I also thought that it might be interesting, since I’m in uncharted territory a little bit, to document what worked and what didn’t in the puzzle making process. But first, the puzzle (rules for solving the puzzle can be found here):

I wrote a little algorithm to generate a map for the puzzle. I then placed the numbers myself and made some minor edits. I hope there is a unique solution. If not, someone please comment to let me know. Here’s what I learned in this iteration:
- The original puzzle that I generated was ambiguous and could not be disambiguated as it stood. To see what I mean, try to solve the puzzle after removing the 1 from the fourth row, last column. You’ll see that the square could be either land or water. In my original puzzle it was water. I could think of no number placement that could require the space to be water, so I made it land.
- In general, I think the islands are too big in this puzzle. Having larger islands seemed interesting to me at first but they just make the puzzle easier, at least with a small board. One thing that I learned pretty quickly when I was laying out numbers is that any island larger than 2 is going to require a number in it. Otherwise, the puzzle will be ambiguous.
- I’m working with the theory now that a good mochikoro puzzle is one where you have a single unique solution with the least amount of initial information provided. Having said that, I think I could do much better than the above puzzle.
So, I have a few things to work on for next week. When I post a new puzzle then, I’ll address all of the issues above. For now, enjoy this one! And here’s the solution, if you need it.
Tags:
mochikoro,
nikoli,
puzzles